Lakes: Vegetation |
Back to Applications index |
|
Accurate, cost effective assessment of submerged aquatic vegetation in lakes has been a challenge for managers and researchers for many years. Knowledge of plant presence, distribution and density is essential for understanding essential habitats and for decision making on the control of invasive species. Recent improvements in hydroacoustic hardware and the creation of specialized software have allowed introduction of a revolutionary method of quick and accurate assessment.
The system utilizes a 420 kHz digital echosounder linked to a DGPS and is run in a downward looking mobile survey mode. Post processing with EcoSAV software produces a collection of georeferenced data points along each survey transect. Each data point contains information on mean plant height, bottom coverage of vegetation and water depth.
|
Case Studies
|
Accuracy and Precision of Hydroacoustic Estimates of Aquatic Vegetation and the Repeatability of Whole-Lake Surveys: Field Tests with a Commercial Echosounder. |
|
Hydroacoustics, coupled with GPS and GIS represents a promising tool in monitoring changes to submersed vegetation biovolume, which is important for many Minnesota fish species. However, prior to establishing operational survey programs using these technologies, the performance of the equipment, software, and survey methodology must be rigorously evaluated. Accordingly, we conducted ground-truth experiments with a BioSonics Inc. digital echosounder by comparing estimates of bottom depth, plant height, and depth to the top of the plant made with EcoSAV vegetation analysis software with measurements made with divers. EcoSAV-estimated and diver-measured plant heights did not differ significantly, however, the EcoSAV-estimated position of the plant in the water column did differ from the diver-measured position. On average, EcoSAV over-estimated bottom depth by 0.18 m and over-estimated the depth from the surface to the top of the plant by 0.23 m. As a result, the EcoSAV estimates indicated that plants occupied less of the water column than divermeasured values. Bias in bottom measurements was likely due to signal penetration of the soft sediments in Square Lake by the echosounder. Bias in top of plant measurements was likely a result of difficulty placing the transducer directly over the marker buoys, so the top of the plant sometimes fell outside and above the acoustic cone. We also evaluated whether boat navigation error affected the accuracy and precision of vegetation maps, and the repeatability of whole-lake surveys. To do so, we conducted surveys on three consecutive days in two diversely vegetated lakes. Boat navigation RMSE averaged 3.5 to 4.0 meters; however, GPS location error was only ± 1.06 m. These errors had little effect on the overall accuracy and precision of maps of biovolume in both lakes. Precision of biovolume estimates was lower at depths less than 2 meters than at deeper depths. |
|
Document Links:
Accuracy and Precision of Hydroacoustic Estimates of Aquatic Vegetation and the Repeatability of Whole-Lake Surveys: Field Tests with a Commercial Echosounder.
|
Product Link:
EcoSAV
|
|
Assessment in two shallow lakes of a hydroacoustic system for surveying aquatic macrophytes |
|
A technique for the rapid surveying of submersed aquatic vegetation by post-processing of data collected using a high frequency (420 kHz) digital echo sounder (BioSonics DT4000) has recently been developed and successfully tested in an estuarine environment by Sabol et al. [Sabol, B. M., R. E. Melton, R. Chamberlain, P. Doering & K. Haunert, 2002. Evaluation of a digital echo sounder system for detection of submersed aquatic vegetation. Estuaries 25: 133141.], where it was used to map the cover and height of freshwater tape grass (Vallisneria americana) and seagrasses (Thalassia testudinum, Haladule wrightii and Syringodium filiforme). This technique, which is also spatially referenced by input from a global positioning system, has many potential applications in macrophyte studies in shallow lakes, although it has not yet been extensively tested in such habitats using systems of lower sound frequency. This paper reports such a test in two shallow (maximum depth c. 5.9 m) lakes of the Cotswold Water Park, U.K., using a 200 kHz digital echo sounder (BioSonics DT6000 and DT-X upgrade) and post-processing analysis using the now commercially available software EcoSAV, which incorporates the algorithms of Sabol et al. (2002). Hydroacoustic assessment of the coverage by macrophytes, mainly Nuttalls pondweed (Elodea nuttallii) and charophytes (Chara spp.), showed high agreement with those recorded during a simultaneous visual survey by underwater video recording (r 2 = 0.8478, n = 74, P < 0.001). Assessment of macrophyte height was also apparently consistent between the two systems, although the video system could not produce quantitative data and so statistical assessment of the agreement was not possible. Repeated hydroacoustic surveys over the course of the winter of 20032004 were conducted in one lake and illustrate the application of this new macrophyte survey technique. Such applications include the rapid measurement of mean Percentage Volume Inhabited (PVI), which fell from 12.15% (95% confidence limits, ±0.55%) to 7.10% (±0.40%) over the course of the winter. |
|
Document Links:
Assessment in two shallow lakes of a hydroacoustic system for surveying aquatic macrophytes
|
Product Link:
DT Series
|
|
Developing Plans for Managing Invasive Aquatic Plants in Mississippi Water Resources |
|
Invasive aquatic plants are an ever-growing nuisance to water resources in Mississippi and the
rest of the United States. These plants are generally introduced from other parts of the world,
some for beneficial or horticultural uses. Once introduced, they can interfere with navigation,
impede water flow, increase flood risk, reduce hydropower generation, and increase
evapotranspirational losses from surface waters. Invasive species also pose direct threats to
ecosystems processes and biodiversity. All agencies and individuals responsible for water
resources in Mississippi should be prepared for invasive aquatic plants through developing an
aquatic plant management plan. Components of a plan include: Prevention, Problem
Assessment, Project Management, Education, Monitoring, Site- or problem-specific management
goals, and Evaluation. |
|
Document Links:
Developing Plans for Managing Invasive Aquatic Plants in Mississippi Water Resources
|
|
|
Developing Plans for Managing Invasive Aquatic Plants in Mississippi Water Resources |
|
Invasive aquatic plants are an ever-growing nuisance to water resources in Mississippi and the
rest of the United States. These plants are generally introduced from other parts of the world,
some for beneficial or horticultural uses. Once introduced, they can interfere with navigation,
impede water flow, increase flood risk, reduce hydropower generation, and increase
evapotranspirational losses from surface waters. Invasive species also pose direct threats to
ecosystems processes and biodiversity. All agencies and individuals responsible for water
resources in Mississippi should be prepared for invasive aquatic plants through developing an
aquatic plant management plan. Components of a plan include: Prevention, Problem
Assessment, Project Management, Education, Monitoring, Site- or problem-specific management
goals, and Evaluation. |
|
Document Links:
Developing Plans for Managing Invasive Aquatic Plants in Mississippi Water Resources
|
Product Link:
DT-X
|
|
EcoSAV and GIS to Measure Aquatic Plant Habitats in Minnesota Lakes |
The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, along with other environmental agencies and interest groups, are continually working towards maintaining or improving water quality and lake habitats. Native plants are an integral part of a healthy ecosystem, but watersheds are threatening these aquatic plants. The DNR is currently exploring whether EcoSAV with GIS together can monitor changes in aquatic plant communities as they relate to fish habitat. |
|
Document Links:
EcoSAV and GIS to Measure Aquatic Plant Habitats in Minnesota Lakes
|
Product Link:
EcoSAV
|
|
Innovative Techniques for Improved Hydroacoustic Bottom Tracking in Dense Aquatic Vegetation |
|
The basis for acoustical bathymetric surveys is detecting and timing the echo from a short, vertically oriented pulse. The exact detection process may vary from system to system but is usually based on exceedence of some minimum threshold intensity and peak width. For bathymetric surveys of navigation channels, this approach usually works well. A typical navigation channel consists of open water above a distinct sediment interface, leading to no ambiguity in relating the time of the echoed pulse to the exact depth of the sediment interface. A decided exception to this occurs when the bottom is colonized with submersed aquatic vegetation. Under these conditions, the acoustical reflectivity of the gas-filled plant stems or blades generates an echo that arrives at the receiver before the true bottom echo. Depending on plant type, height, and density, these plant-generated returns may pass the test for the detected bottom and be declared as the bottom, underestimating the true depth. If undetected, this condition can lead to erroneous surveys of channel depth and overestimates of dredging quantities required to keep the channel at its authorized depth. |
|
Document Links:
Innovative Techniques for Improved Hydroacoustic Bottom Tracking in Dense Aquatic Vegetation
|
Product Link:
DT-X
|
|
Integrating Acoustic Mapping into Operational Aquatic Plant Management: a case study in Wisconsin |
|
Efficient planning, execution, and post-treatment monitoring of a submersed aquatic plant management operation require early detection and detailed information on the distribution of target and nontarget species within the treated waterbody. This requirement was the motivation behind the development of the acoustic-based Submersed Aquatic Vegetation Early Warning System (SAVEWS TM). After initial development in the late 1990s, the associated processing software was licensed to Biosonics, Inc., and is currently marketed as EcoSAV TM, along with the required hardware for conducting acoustic plant surveys. Since becoming commercially available in 2001, approximately 70 systems are in use world wide. While the system is used by a number of aquatic plant management researchers and operators, by far greater use is found in other fields, primarily ecological and applied studies of estuarine vegetation and coastal hydrography. While usage in any form is considered beneficial, a significant potential for operational usage within the aquatic plant management field is largely unrealized. Discussions with various aquatic plant management personnel identified concerns related to using the system operationally, including system acquisition and operations cost, data processing complexity, data accuracy, and acceptance by regulatory agencies. To address these concerns, a mapping demonstration was performed in conjunction with a chemical control application to treat Eurasian watermilfoil (Myriophyllum spicatum) in a 515-acre (2.08 km2) Wisconsin lake. One pretreatment and 2 post-treatment surveys were conducted. A ground-truth sampling effort was performed as part of the first post-treatment survey. The cost of conducting the mapping survey is broken out in terms of equipment costs and labor for planning, execution, and data analysis. We present techniques and summaries for data analysis and evaluate the added value of information provided by acoustic mapping to the overall management operation. |
|
Document Links:
Integrating Acoustic Mapping into Operational Aquatic Plant Management: a case study in Wisconsin
|
|
|
Monitoring and Mapping of Submersed Aquatic Vegetation in Lake Washington, Seattle |
Recent developments in classifying bottom substrates and quantifying underwater vegetation make hydroacoustics an effective tool for monitoring and mapping habitat parameters in aquatic ecosystems. This study incorporated hydroacoustic sampling for bathymetry, substrate type, underwater vegetation, and fish distribution in Lake Washington, Seattle, USA. Data were collected using three independent echo sounder systems, to maximize data accuracy and vessel use, and geo-referenced using a Differential Global Positioning System, enabling the acoustic data to be used in a Geographic Information System. Results indicated that aquatic vegetation was limited to depths less than 8 m. This method proved to be an effective way to study various habitat influences on fish distribution, as well as map and monitor important physical and seasonal habitat parameters such as bathymetry, bottom character, and aquatic vegetation distribution. Recent advances in seabed classification and submersed aquatic vegetation (SAV) detection using acoustic technology have made it possible to collect acoustic data on bathymetry, substrata type, plant coverage and height, and fish abundance and distribution. However, each type of acoustic application has optimal beam-width, frequency and pulse-width requirements for data collection. For example, when working in shallow water environments (0-100 m), bottom classification will require a low frequency, wide-beam echo sounder system; aquatic vegetation will require a high frequency, narrow-beam echo sounder system and fish data collection will require a 38-420 kHz, narrow-beam echo sounder. This may appear to expand the time and effort required to collect and process multiple types of acoustic data. However, by using multiple digital echo sounder systems, the entire data set can be collected in a single acoustic field survey, greatly enhancing the speed in which the data may be acquired. Two recently developed software packages, BioSonics EcoSAV® and VBT Seabed Classifier, were used for data analysis. EcoSAV is designed to quantify SAV from hydroacoustic data. The software requires a digital echo sounder (BioSonics), differential GPS (DGPS) and computer for data acquisition. The echo sounder system collects and stores the digital echo signal from the echo sounder (either split- or single-beam) and DGPS data (latitude, longitude and time). The echosounder used to collect SAV distribution data was a DE 420 kHz, 6º split-beam echo sounder set to 0.1 ms pulse-width, 5 pings s-1, and a threshold of 130 dB. The processing algorithms in EcoSAV determine bottom depth, plant presence/absence, plant height, and aerial coverage. A survey map was designed with a commercial navigation software package using BSB format maps produced by the United States National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association (NOAA). The navigation software was operated simultaneously with the hydroacoustic acquisition software in order to collect data along preestablished transects. The signal from an onboard Differential Global Positioning System (DGPS) was fed into both the navigation package and acoustic data collection software so that all data collected were concurrently geo-referenced. Upon completion of the data acquisition, the data was processed to extract SAV height and cover. Accurate two-dimensional ground measurements (e.g., length, area) required that the DGPS data be mathematically transformed into a map projection system appropriate to the area of interest. All other data was subsequently imported into a GIS database for integration and mapping. EcoSAV calculations of plant height, water depth, and percent bottom coverage were transformed into percent plant biovolume: the percentage of water column with vegetation at a given report location. This transformation was performed by multiplying percent bottom cover by the ratio of plant height to water depth. Geospatial surface models were developed from final data on percent plant biovolume, percent bottom cover, sediment type, and bathymetry. Aquatic vegetation was distributed widely and covered almost 60% of the survey area, but was confined to depths less than 8 m, presumably due to light-limitation. The highest density patches reached 100% cover, were relatively uniform in cover, and were most common in water less than 3 m deep. By biovolume, the greatest proportion of the area surveyed had plants that were between 1-19% of the water column. Three patches with high biovolume were observed: the northeast corner, the northwest corner, and along the west side of the area surveyed. Overall, the study demonstrated that the various echo sounder systems could be combined to yield a wealth of data on aquatic habitat and fish distribution. Integrating the data in GIS was an effective way to evaluate fish distribution in regards to bathymetric features, substrate types, and patches of aquatic vegetation. |
|
Document Links:
Digital Acoustic System to Monitor & Map Ecosystem
|
Product Link:
EcoSAV
|
|
Operating Instructions Manual for the Acoustic-Based Submeresed Aquatic Plant Mapping System |
This brief instruction set is intended to serve as a guide for the use of the ERDC-developed
Submersed Aquatic Vegetation Early Warning System (SAVEWS) embodied in the Biosonics
DT-X sounder with a Leica MX-420 DGPS Navigation System and a Panosonic Toughbook
computer. Instructions are written around the Biosonics Visual Acquisition software (version
5.0.3), Biosonics EcoSAV software (version 1.0) which contains the windows SAVEWS
software, and the Leica MX-420 software (version 1.5). These instructions are not intended to
replace the separate instruction manuals for these components. Rather, the user is encouraged
to study these separate manuals and to use this instruction set as a reminder during field
operations. |
|
Document Links:
Operating Instructions Manual For The Acoustic-Based Submersed Aquatic Plant Mapping System
|
Product Link:
EcoSAV
|
|
Quantification of Historical Changes of Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Cover in Two Bays of Lake Ontario with Three Complementary Methods |
|
Submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV) distribution and coverage were quantified in two bays of Lake Ontario in 1972, 1980 (1982), and 19992002, using a combination of aerial photograph interpretation (API), hydroacoustics, and rake sampling. The three methods gave similar estimates of SAV presence in 2002, supporting our use of API for quantifying SAV changes across decades in bays of a large lake. The SAV coverage in Sodus Bay increased by 5% between 1972 and 1980 and by 35% between 1980 and 19992002 whereas the maximum depth of SAV colonization extended from 5.5 to 6.4 m during this period. In Chaumont Bay, the SAV coverage tripled while its maximum depth of occurrence increased from 5.1 to 6.1 m from 1982 to 2002. Although the difference in SAV coverage between 1972 and 1980 was not larger than the difference between consecutive years in the 2000s, the large increase in SAV coverage between the 1980s and 2000s represents a major ecosystem change in these bays. This change was likely caused by increased water clarity in Lake Ontario, which could be associated with the implementation of the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement (GLWQA) and the dreissenid mussel invasion. Although other factors such as water level, wave exposure, bottom slope, and sediment nutrients may be important, they have not changed in a fashion that would predict local increases of SAV coverage. |
|
Document Links:
Quantification of Historical Changes of Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Cover in Two Bays of Lake Ontario with Three Complementary Methods
|
Product Link:
DT-X
|
|
Quantifying submerged aquatic vegetation using aerial photograph interpretation : Application in studies assessing fish habitat in freshwater ecosystems |
|
Use of aerial photograph interpretation (API) in resource inventory projects recently has increased, and this reflects benefits like established protocols, high spatial resolution, readily available photography, and limited cost. Application of API to quantify features of aquatic habitats used by fishes, like submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV), has been advocated for decades but a paucity of use suggests inadequate awareness of the methods. This article reviews a protocol that guides the use of API to quantify features of aquatic habitats, and then uses examples from contrasting habitats in the Lake Ontario watershed from 1972-2003 to illustrate this protocol. Even though we used photographs originally collected for other purposes, API identified the change in minimum area and depth distribution of SAV over time. These observations reinforce how API can contribute information to resource inventories, and why investigators should expand use of API in studies of aquatic ecosystems. |
|
Document Links:
Quantifying submerged aquatic vegetation using aerial photograph interpretation : Application in studies assessing fish habitat in freshwater ecosystems
|
Product Link:
DT-X
|
|
Use of Acoustics for Detecting Aquatic Vegetation (7.1) |
Underwater acoustics can be used for monitoring and mapping of ecosystem. Information on bottom substrata and also
on submerged aquatic vegetation is encoded in echo signal. This information can be decoded from survey data as well
as information on fish and plankton distribution and size. BioSonics has developed two sets of algorithms and data
analysis software packages for this purpose: (a) SAVEWS (Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Early Warning System) was
developed under joint research program with USACE and (b) VBT (Seabed Classifier). In both programs we started
with theoretical studies on appropriate method of echo signal processing. The second step was testing of various
processing algorithms by acquiring ground truth (verified) data on submerged plants and bottom categories using digital
echosounders DT series. After testing of processing algorithms we developed user-friendly software packages. Survey
data can be acquired in geographical context and survey maps can be generated. Echo signal processing algorithms are
described (see document link). Detection performance of the system and few case studies in marine environment and also in freshwater are
discussed. |
|
Document Links:
Use of Acoustics for Detecting Aquatic Vegetation
|
Product Link:
EcoSAV
|
|
Use of Acoustics for Detecting Aquatic Vegetation (7.2) |
The coverage with two species of Zostera, Z. marina (L.) and Z. noltii (Hornem.) in the river Asón estuary near
Santoña, Cantabria/Spain has been assessed between August and October 2000, using a BioSonics DT 6000 208kHz
split beam digital echosounder in combination with a DGPS receiver and a reference station. A surface of roughly
4sqkm has been covered with transects spaced 20m on average, resulting in a total track length of about 250km, taking
some 800,000 samples (pings). A pre-release version of a specific software, based on SAVEWS (Submersed Aquatic
Vegetation Early Warning System), developed by Bruce Sabol, USACE Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg,
and currently under further development through BioSonics, Inc., Seattle, was deployed in order to process the split
beam raw data (only single beam data is read by the program). Previous to the survey, a number of fixed position
observations over a frame (50x50cm) were done in order to dispose of data for calibration purposes. Afterwards the
frame area has been fully sampled physically. Data on existence of plants as detected by the program was verified
comparing the findings with the echograms. The percentage of plant detection over a cycle of 8 pings as a measure for
the density or coverage of detected plants and plant mean height are also available from the program output. These
parameters have been interpolated and subsequently presented on maps. Additionally, ground truth data from 100
physical field samples is available to verify findings. The desire to distinguish the two species present in the area,
Zostera marina and Zostera noltii, was not yet achieved based on the obtained data. Due to the specific configuration of
the equipment during data acquisition, TS analysis with common tools are not easily done. An empirical approach to
separate species based on a combination of height and depth has not yet concluded. Finally, a series of problems, as for
example the inclination of plants due to currents, are discussed (see attached document). |
|
Document Links:
Use of Acoustics for Detecting Aquatic Vegetation
|
Product Link:
DT-X
|
|
What does resilience of a clear-water state in lakes mean for the spatial heterogeneity of submersed macrophyte biovolume? |
|
Short-term variability of spatial heterogeneity of submersed macrophyte biovolume (percent of water column occupied by vegetation) was evaluated over 3 years along a gradient of productivity in four north temperate glacial lakes in Minnesota, USA. We hypothesized we would observe the lowest among-year variability in spatial heterogeneity of biovolume in our undisturbed, moderately productive lake and high variability in our more locally disturbed productive lakes. Our analysis involved three major steps: first, we removed negative trends of biovolume across depth with non-parametric regression smoothers; second, we examined spatial pattern in residuals using variograms; finally, we compared spatial pattern of biovolume among lakes seasonally, over 3 years. Lake productivity negatively correlated with water clarity and the depth range of macrophyte growth, and positively correlated with the variability of spatial patterns. In the least disturbed moderately productive lake, vegetation grew over a large range of depths (up to 7.5 m), and spatial pattern across the littoral zone was similar for each survey. In contrast, in the more turbid, productive lakes, depth and spatial patterns of biovolume varied greatly from survey to survey. Factors that increase productivity and weaken resilience in lakes may lead to unstable spatial patterns of macrophyte biovolume. |
|
Document Links:
What does resilience of a clear-water state in lakes mean for the spatial heterogeneity of submersed macrophyte biovolume?
|
Product Link:
DT-X
|
|